Truck Brake Failures and Mechanical Defects: Who’s Responsible?

Understanding Liability in Brake-Related Truck Accidents

When a commercial truck crashes because of brake failure or a mechanical defect, the results are often catastrophic. In Georgia, these types of wrecks frequently involve jackknife crashes, runaway trucks, or high-speed rear-end collisions—especially on major interstates like I-75, I-20, and I-285.

Unlike typical motor vehicle accidents, brake-related truck wrecks often expose deeper safety failures: missed inspections, poor maintenance, or cost-cutting at the expense of public safety. If you’ve been injured in one of these wrecks, a Georgia truck accident attorney can help you uncover what went wrong and pursue justice from all responsible parties.

How Truck Brake Systems Can Fail

Brake systems on large trucks are complex and require constant upkeep. When something goes wrong, the consequences are immediate. Common causes of brake failure include:

• Worn Brake Pads Or Shoes: Without proper friction materials, stopping distances increase drastically.
• Air Brake Malfunctions: Many trucks rely on air brakes, which require a specific pressure range to function. A leak, valve issue, or compressor failure can disable the system.
• Overheated Brakes: Excessive braking on downgrades or stop-and-go routes can lead to brake fade.
• Oil Or Grease Contamination: Leaks from other components can reduce braking power and cause skidding.
• Defective Or Mismatched Parts: Using incompatible components or failing to follow manufacturer specs often leads to early failure.

Many of these issues could be prevented with routine maintenance and proper training. But too often, trucking companies fail to prioritize safety—putting everyone else on the road at risk.

Who’s Liable When Brake Failure Causes a Truck Crash in Georgia?

After a serious wreck, it’s not enough to blame the truck driver alone. Liability can extend to multiple parties, each of whom may have played a role in the failure.

Possible liable parties include:

• The Trucking Company: If the company ignored maintenance schedules, used unqualified mechanics, or pressured drivers to skip inspections, they can be held accountable.
• The Driver: Federal rules require drivers to conduct pre-trip and post-trip inspections. If they skipped a walkaround or failed to report brake problems, they may share responsibility.
• A Repair Contractor Or Mechanic: Third-party service providers who performed negligent repairs can also be held liable.
• Parts Manufacturers Or Distributors: If the brake system or component failed due to a design flaw, manufacturing defect, or recall issue, a product liability claim may apply.
• Shippers And Loaders: In some cases, improper cargo loading can stress braking systems and cause failures—especially if the load exceeds capacity or shifts during transport.

Each of these possibilities requires detailed investigation, including analysis of black box data, maintenance logs, service contracts, and post-crash inspections.

The Role of Federal Brake Safety Regulations

The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) sets strict guidelines for commercial truck safety, including minimum standards for brake performance. Trucks must be able to stop within a certain distance based on weight and speed, and they must undergo routine inspections, especially for air brakes.

If a trucking company or driver violates FMCSA brake safety rules, that can be used as evidence of negligence in your injury claim.

Common violations include:

• Operating with brake linings below thickness limits
• Driving with inoperative or contaminated brakes
• Failing to perform required periodic brake inspections
• Exceeding hours-of-service limits, which can lead to rushed inspections or ignored red flags

When these failures happen, it’s not just a technical issue—it’s a preventable act of negligence.

How Brake Failure Accidents Happen in Real Life

Picture this scenario: A fully loaded tractor-trailer is descending a steep grade in North Georgia. The driver taps the brakes, but the vehicle doesn’t slow. The truck barrels through a red light at the bottom of the hill and plows into stopped traffic, injuring multiple drivers and killing one.

An investigation reveals that the truck’s air brake system was leaking pressure. The driver had noted issues during the last trip, but the company failed to schedule a repair—and pressured him to keep driving.

In this case, the brake failure wasn’t a surprise. It was a known issue ignored by the company and disregarded by a driver trying to keep his job. When these choices lead to tragedy, victims have the right to demand full accountability.

Other Mechanical Defects That Lead to Catastrophic Truck Crashes

While brake failures are among the most common mechanical issues, other defects can be just as deadly—especially when trucks are hauling thousands of pounds at highway speeds.

Common mechanical failures include:

• Steering System Defects: Faulty or worn steering components can cause a truck to veer into other lanes or lose control entirely.
• Blown Tires: A sudden tire blowout, especially on a front axle, can lead to rollover crashes or cause the truck to jackknife.
• Lighting Or Signal Failures: If a truck’s brake lights, turn signals, or hazard lights aren’t working, nearby drivers have no warning during stops or turns—leading to rear-end or side-impact collisions.
• Suspension Failures: Broken springs, shocks, or other suspension components can destabilize the truck and make it harder to control on uneven or curved roads.
• Transmission Or Engine Malfunctions: Sudden power loss or gear lock-up can cause a truck to stall in traffic or lurch unexpectedly.

When mechanical defects are caused by skipped inspections, faulty repairs, or defective parts, victims have the right to pursue claims against the responsible parties. These are not “accidents”—they’re preventable safety failures that demand accountability.

Brake Failure and Runaway Truck Accidents

A runaway truck accident is one of the most terrifying outcomes of brake failure. These incidents often occur on steep downgrades or long highway stretches, where overheated brakes fail to slow the vehicle. Without a functioning brake system, the truck barrels out of control—endangering every driver in its path.

These crashes often involve:

• Total brake system failure on downhill grades
• Overloaded trucks exceeding safe braking capacity
• Drivers missing or ignoring runaway truck ramps
• Wrecks at the base of hills where trucks fail to stop in time

When a runaway truck crash happens, the results are often fatal. These are not freak accidents—they’re the result of poor maintenance, unsafe loading practices, or failure to train drivers on mountain-grade procedures.

Why Evidence Disappears Fast After a Brake Failure Wreck

When brakes fail, companies often move quickly to recover the truck, fix the issue, or shift blame. If you wait too long, critical evidence may be lost, including:

• Black box data showing brake use or lack thereof
• Repair logs or defect complaints filed before the crash
• Surveillance footage at the scene
• Inspection reports from law enforcement or the DOT

Trucking companies may also claim the brakes were working fine or that the driver was at fault. That’s why it’s critical to contact a Georgia truck accident attorney immediately after the crash. We send spoliation letters, file emergency motions, and preserve the full scope of evidence before it’s gone.

What Compensation Can You Recover?

Brake failure crashes often cause high-speed, high-impact collisions—especially rear-end and underride accidents. Victims can seek compensation for:

• Emergency and long-term medical costs
• Lost wages and future earnings
• Pain and suffering
• Permanent disability or disfigurement
• Emotional trauma
• Wrongful death benefits for surviving families
• Punitive damages in cases of gross negligence

At Gary Martin Hays & Associates, we fight to ensure every form of loss is considered—not just what the insurance company wants to pay.

Contact an Experienced Georgia Truck Accident Attorney Today

Brake failures and mechanical defects should never be excused. If you or a loved one was injured in a crash caused by a failed truck component, we’re here to help you pursue the truth and recover the compensation you deserve.

Our legal team has recovered over $1 billion for Georgia families, and we know how to hold trucking companies, mechanics, and manufacturers accountable.

We offer free consultations with no obligation, and you pay nothing unless we win your case. With offices in Atlanta, Duluth, Lithonia, College Park, Marietta, Gainesville, Conyers, and Jonesboro, we’re ready to meet wherever it’s convenient for you.

Click here for a printable PDF of this article, “Truck Brake Failures and Mechanical Defects: Who’s Responsible?”